THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
May 27, 2003
By DAVID S. CLOUD
WASHINGTON -- Senior U.S. officials plan to meet Tuesday to discuss Iran after authorities there said they had no knowledge that any senior al Qaeda leaders were operating from Iranian territory.
Tensions between Washington and Tehran have escalated this month over U.S. charges that car bombings in Saudi Arabia may have been overseen by al Qaeda leaders in Iran -- part of a pattern, U.S. officials assert, of threatening actions emanating from within Iran's borders. Some U.S. officials say intelligence reports of al Qaeda's presence in Iran are strong enough that the Bush administration shouldn't continue even informal diplomatic contacts unless Tehran cooperates in rounding up members of the terrorist network.
Monday, Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asef said Iran has no interest in helping al Qaeda's Islamic militants. A number of the group's members may have slipped into the country illegally, he said, and several are currently under investigation, but none has been identified as a senior member. "We do not know who these are. How can we say that they are senior members of al Qaeda or not?" he said, according to IRNA, the official Iranian news agency.
Tuesday's White House meeting on Iran, which also will involve senior State Department and Pentagon officials, is meant to assess how responsive Tehran is being to U.S. requests, sent through British diplomats and a United Nations official last week, for movement against the alleged al Qaeda presence in Iran. White House envoy Zalmay Khalilzad has held periodic meetings with Iranian officials in Geneva, but a planned meeting last week was canceled to emphasize U.S. desire for action, administration officials said.
Unless Iranian authorities take more steps against al Qaeda in coming days, Tehran's stance is likely to bolster hard-liners in the Bush administration who have been arguing for several months that the U.S. should adopt a more confrontational stance toward Iran. Since the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, administration officials have accused Tehran of sending agents to foment anti-U.S. sentiment among Iraq's Shiite Muslims, continuing to back anti-Israel terror groups and stepping up a clandestine nuclear-weapons program. U.S. hard-liners are arguing for steps aimed at destabilizing the Iranian regime from within. President Bush has said U.S. policy toward Iran seeks regime change, but officials say he hasn't resolved how aggressively to pursue that, except to play down the option of using military force.
The U.S. is particularly interested in the whereabouts of Saef al-Adel, an Egyptian militant linked to al Qaeda who U.S. officials say is believed to have been in Iran recently. U.S. officials say they have intercepted telephone conversations believed to involve Mr. Adel or his associates from inside Iran discussing the May 12 car bombings in the Saudi capital of Riyadh, in which 34 people -- including eight Americans -- were killed. Iranian officials said during the weekend that they had no information about Mr. Adel.
Even within the Bush administration, a number of questions surround the recent intelligence, including whether the overheard conversations involved individuals planning the attacks or just discussing them afterward. Some U.S. officials say that, while al Qaeda members appear to be in Iran, there is no evidence contradicting the Iranian government's claim that it isn't assisting the group. Other officials argue that Iran's hard-line Revolutionary Guards, who are known to support other terrorist groups such as Hezbollah, probably are providing some covert assistance to al Qaeda.
The internal U.S. debate mirrors similar disagreements last year about whether Iraq under Saddam Hussein was directly aiding al Qaeda in an alliance against the U.S. Little information backing that claim has emerged since the U.S. invasion.
"It's unclear exactly what the full Iranian involvement with the al Qaeda people is," a senior intelligence official said. "There are certainly some [in the administration] who take a hard-core view, and others who say we don't know."
In addition to al Qaeda's activities in the region, much of the U.S.-Iran tension these days has to do with events in Iraq. Iranian officials have angrily accused Washington of failing to live up fully to prewar promises to eradicate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, an anti-Tehran militia group that for years has mounted cross-border attacks from Iraq.
Although U.S. forces in Iraq now are moving to disarm the group, they also are insisting that an Iraqi Shiite militia known as the Badr Brigades, which was trained and armed by Iranian Revolutionary Guards, turn over all weapons by next month. Tens of thousands of the group's fighters are said to have returned to Iraq after the war and Tehran is likely to view the U.S. move as a way to limit the power of its Iraqi allies in any new Baghdad government.
This blog aims to be a reference site for what high courts and highly prominent US officials, policy makers and members of the US Congress are saying about the need to for the US Department State to expeditiously remove the Iranian democratic opposition, The People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran (PMOI), also known as the Mujahedin-e Khale (MEK), from the State Department's list of Foreign Terrorist Organizations (FTO).
Tuesday, May 27, 2003
Tuesday, May 13, 2003
U.S.-Iran Talks Underscore Difficulties in Restoring Ties
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
May 13, 2003
By DAVID S. CLOUD
WASHINGTON -- Bush administration officials have met with Iranian representatives in Geneva for talks on postwar Iraq, but the discussions haven't dealt with restoring diplomatic relations between Washington and Tehran, U.S. and Iranian officials said.
In fact, the talks appear to have underscored their differences. At a meeting earlier this month, senior White House aide Zalmay Khalilzad described U.S. concerns that Tehran might be seeking to disrupt the U.S.-run process for creating a new Iraqi government. Iranian officials complained that the U.S. hadn't followed through on prewar promises to shut down an anti-Tehran militia group, Mujahedin-e-Khalq, that has conducted raids for years from bases in Iraq.
"U.S. officials have shown over the past months that they are not committed to pursuing mutual respect in dealing with Iran," said Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi, who was quoted by Iran's official news agency. That apparently was a reference to U.S. efforts in recent weeks to persuade the International Atomic Energy Agency to find that Iran is violating the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty by pursuing a weapons program, which Tehran denies.
U.S. officials portrayed the meeting as part of regular contacts with Tehran that began before the 2001 war in Afghanistan, but that didn't reflect any movement toward restoring diplomatic ties. "This is not somehow a new opening of diplomatic relations. This is an opportunity to deal with some practical issues," said State Department spokesman Philip Reeker.
But the talks, first reported by USA Today, come at a time when the U.S. is grappling internally with whether to maintain a tough stance toward Tehran or ease tensions that have escalated sharply since the U.S. invasion of Iraq. Some senior officials in the Bush administration say Iran's pursuit of weapons of mass destruction and support of anti-Israeli terrorist groups make it the major remaining source of instability in the Middle East. These officials argue for a policy of confronting the Iranian regime in hopes of destabilizing it from within.
Other officials, mainly at the State Department, say that the U.S. needs to reach an understanding with Tehran if it hopes to achieve its near-term goal of building a new Iraqi government. A similar debate about how to deal with the U.S. is going on inside the Iranian government.
Mr. Khalilzad said at the recent meeting that the U.S. intended to follow through on disarming the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, according to two officials. A cease-fire agreement reached by U.S. forces with the MEK, which is listed by the U.S. as a terrorist organization, has angered Iran.
Mr. Asefi made clear that Tehran is watching whether Washington complies with its original promise. Iran fears the U.S. intends to keep the group intact so it can harass Iranians in the future. "We have informed the U.S. through various channels that there is no good or bad terrorist," he said.
May 13, 2003
By DAVID S. CLOUD
WASHINGTON -- Bush administration officials have met with Iranian representatives in Geneva for talks on postwar Iraq, but the discussions haven't dealt with restoring diplomatic relations between Washington and Tehran, U.S. and Iranian officials said.
In fact, the talks appear to have underscored their differences. At a meeting earlier this month, senior White House aide Zalmay Khalilzad described U.S. concerns that Tehran might be seeking to disrupt the U.S.-run process for creating a new Iraqi government. Iranian officials complained that the U.S. hadn't followed through on prewar promises to shut down an anti-Tehran militia group, Mujahedin-e-Khalq, that has conducted raids for years from bases in Iraq.
"U.S. officials have shown over the past months that they are not committed to pursuing mutual respect in dealing with Iran," said Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi, who was quoted by Iran's official news agency. That apparently was a reference to U.S. efforts in recent weeks to persuade the International Atomic Energy Agency to find that Iran is violating the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty by pursuing a weapons program, which Tehran denies.
U.S. officials portrayed the meeting as part of regular contacts with Tehran that began before the 2001 war in Afghanistan, but that didn't reflect any movement toward restoring diplomatic ties. "This is not somehow a new opening of diplomatic relations. This is an opportunity to deal with some practical issues," said State Department spokesman Philip Reeker.
But the talks, first reported by USA Today, come at a time when the U.S. is grappling internally with whether to maintain a tough stance toward Tehran or ease tensions that have escalated sharply since the U.S. invasion of Iraq. Some senior officials in the Bush administration say Iran's pursuit of weapons of mass destruction and support of anti-Israeli terrorist groups make it the major remaining source of instability in the Middle East. These officials argue for a policy of confronting the Iranian regime in hopes of destabilizing it from within.
Other officials, mainly at the State Department, say that the U.S. needs to reach an understanding with Tehran if it hopes to achieve its near-term goal of building a new Iraqi government. A similar debate about how to deal with the U.S. is going on inside the Iranian government.
Mr. Khalilzad said at the recent meeting that the U.S. intended to follow through on disarming the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, according to two officials. A cease-fire agreement reached by U.S. forces with the MEK, which is listed by the U.S. as a terrorist organization, has angered Iran.
Mr. Asefi made clear that Tehran is watching whether Washington complies with its original promise. Iran fears the U.S. intends to keep the group intact so it can harass Iranians in the future. "We have informed the U.S. through various channels that there is no good or bad terrorist," he said.
Monday, May 12, 2003
Official: U.S., Iran, Held Secret Talks
Associated Press
12 May 03
By BARRY SCHWEID
CAIRO, Egypt - The United States and Iran held several meetings in Geneva, Switzerland, in an effort to ease friction between the two countries, a senior U.S. official said Monday.
The meetings focused on a wide range of issues, including postwar Iraq, in which the Bush administration is attempting to deter Iran from trying to influence the formation of a new government in Baghdad.
Secretary of State Colin Powell, during a news conference here after a meeting with Egyptian officials, said the administration opposes a fundamentalist regime as not being in the interest of the Iraqi people.
Powell echoed a similar statement weeks ago by Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, who said establishment of an Iranian-style fundamentalist government would be unacceptable to the United States.
The official, who spoke condition on anonymity, said the meetings in Geneva were technically under the auspices of the United Nations.
USA Today, reporting on the talks in Monday's editions, said the government of Iran was weighing the possibility of reopening diplomatic relations with the United States for the first time in nearly a quarter century.
The official Iranian news agency on Monday quoted Foreign Ministry Spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi saying the discussions were about the work in Afghanistan and were conducted through the auspices of the Swiss Embassy in Tehran.
"During these negotiations, the issue of bilateral relations was not on the agenda and no negotiations were held in that regard," he was quoted as saying by the IRNA news agency in Tehran.
Powell, on a flight Saturday to the Middle East, said the United States has long been in communication with Iran through various channels.
However, he said at the time that the administration was not trying to restore diplomatic relations with Tehran, which were broken off in 1979, when militants overran the U.S. embassy and took dozens of Americans as hostages.
12 May 03
By BARRY SCHWEID
CAIRO, Egypt - The United States and Iran held several meetings in Geneva, Switzerland, in an effort to ease friction between the two countries, a senior U.S. official said Monday.
The meetings focused on a wide range of issues, including postwar Iraq, in which the Bush administration is attempting to deter Iran from trying to influence the formation of a new government in Baghdad.
Secretary of State Colin Powell, during a news conference here after a meeting with Egyptian officials, said the administration opposes a fundamentalist regime as not being in the interest of the Iraqi people.
Powell echoed a similar statement weeks ago by Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, who said establishment of an Iranian-style fundamentalist government would be unacceptable to the United States.
The official, who spoke condition on anonymity, said the meetings in Geneva were technically under the auspices of the United Nations.
USA Today, reporting on the talks in Monday's editions, said the government of Iran was weighing the possibility of reopening diplomatic relations with the United States for the first time in nearly a quarter century.
The official Iranian news agency on Monday quoted Foreign Ministry Spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi saying the discussions were about the work in Afghanistan and were conducted through the auspices of the Swiss Embassy in Tehran.
"During these negotiations, the issue of bilateral relations was not on the agenda and no negotiations were held in that regard," he was quoted as saying by the IRNA news agency in Tehran.
Powell, on a flight Saturday to the Middle East, said the United States has long been in communication with Iran through various channels.
However, he said at the time that the administration was not trying to restore diplomatic relations with Tehran, which were broken off in 1979, when militants overran the U.S. embassy and took dozens of Americans as hostages.
U.S., Iran Stall On Road to Rapprochement
Bush Administration Divided on How to Resolve Renewed Tensions Over Iraq, Nuclear Plans
The Wall Street Journal
May 12, 2003
By DAVID S. CLOUD
When the Bush administration this month asked the Iranian government through intermediaries to turn over Iraqi officials or terrorists who crossed into their territory, a U.S. official says Tehran's reply was caustic: We had a deal to cooperate, and you haven't lived up to it.
The Iranians were upset that Washington hadn't followed through on prewar assurances that coalition forces invading Iraq would eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, an anti-Tehran militia group that for years has mounted cross-border attacks from Iraq.
The back-channel messages, which the official said were conveyed by British diplomats, show how a relationship that in some ways had been quietly improving after the war in Afghanistan has deteriorated since the invasion of Iraq. Now, U.S. officials accuse Tehran of sending agents to foment anti-U.S. sentiment among Iraq's Shiite Muslims, continuing to back anti-Israel terror groups and stepping up a clandestine nuclear-weapons program.
How the U.S. -- with thousands of troops on Iran's western flank -- confronts these issues has become a major foreign-policy question for the Bush administration. And the issue has revived an internal U.S. government debate about how to deal with Iran , a country the U.S. hasn't had formal relations with since Islamic clerics took power in a 1979 revolution.
Some State Department officials argue that the best way to improve Tehran's behavior, in addition to public pressure, is to quietly signal to people loyal to President Mohammad Khatami that Washington's goals in the region don't include the regime's ouster. If the Iranians don't feel threatened, these officials argue, they will be less apt to meddle in Iraq and may even decide that developing nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles is less urgent.
That view isn't shared by other administration officials. Some in the Pentagon and White House favor a more confrontational approach, based on their view that Iran's hard-line clerics retain too much authority to abandon policies objectionable to Washington without sustained pressure. They argue for steps aimed at destabilizing the Iranian regime from within, including a proposed $50 million fund for pro-democracy radio and satellite broadcasts into the country by Iranian-Americans.
"America must abandon any talk of engaging the self-proclaimed reformers [in Iran ] who have not reformed the system in the seven years they have been in power," says Sen. Sam Brownback, a Kansas Republican who is pushing the broadcasting fund in Congress.
Leading up to the Iraq war, the White House was much more inclined to woo Tehran than it is now. Despite fears about Iranian meddling after the U.S. war in Afghanistan, Iran played a constructive role after that conflict, supporting Hamid Karzai's fledgling government, said former State Department Afghanistan envoy James Dobbins.
U.S. officials hoped that would continue heading into the Iraq conflict. In January, White House aide Zalmay Khalilzad and State Department officials assured Iranian representatives at a meeting in northern Iraq that the imminent U.S. invasion wouldn't threaten -- and might even benefit -- Tehran. The Iranians were told that one of the U.S. war aims was to eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, a longtime Iranian goal. In return, the U.S. asked Iran not to send armed fighters into Iraq, U.S. officials say. Neither side completely complied.
After the hostilities, the Pentagon negotiated a temporary cease-fire that confined the Mujahedin-e-Khalq to bases in eastern Iraq but allowed it to keep its weapons. The arrangement was described as temporary, but it stirred Iranians' fears that the U.S. wanted the group intact to harass them in the future.
Pentagon officials wrote a memo last month suggesting that the White House could consider naming the Mujahedin-e-Khalq "a legitimate Iranian opposition group," despite its status as a U.S.-designated terrorist group, according to a U.S. official who quoted from the document. A Pentagon spokesman denied the department had proposed the idea, but the group's future was discussed at a senior-level meeting two weeks ago, officials said. The State Department's top counterterrorism official, Cofer Black, argued that would undermine U.S. credibility when it asked other countries to crack down on terrorist groups. Mr. Bush sided with the State Department, and U.S. forces in Iraq now are moving to disarm and eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq.
State Department officials say that decision at least in part is meant to reinforce the message that the U.S. isn't looking to meddle inside Iran -- just as Tehran shouldn't interfere in Iraq.
But U.S. officials say Iranian Revolutionary Guards -- militants loyal to Iran's hard-line clerics -- are seeking to play a role inside Iraq, both by infiltrating the country themselves and by working through Iraqi Shiite clerics, many of whom have spent years living in Iran . Even Iraqis whom the U.S. is counting on to play major roles in an interim Iraqi government have ties to Tehran. One U.S. official said Iranian agents are telling Iraqis that the U.S. doesn't have the stomach for the long haul and will be gone soon. "The message is, 'Don't get too close to the Americans,' " the official said.
Mr. Bush hasn't resolved the disagreement among his advisers, except to play down the option of using military force to achieve regime change in Iran . Secretary of State Colin Powell has little interest in attempting to hold direct talks with the Iranians, as he did recently with the Syrians. Officially, Iran continues to reject direct dialogue with the U.S., but Washington also has spurned what appear to be recent overtures from Tehran that seem to reflect hopes for better relations.
"We do have channels that we are using with the Iranians, and communicating to them that they ought to review their policies," Mr. Powell told reporters during the weekend. He played down the prospect of seeking better ties with Tehran, though. "The issue of diplomatic relations is not on the table right now, on either side."
Since the war ended, the administration has chosen a more confrontational path. Administration officials are trying to build support among governments that sit on the board of the International Atomic Energy Agency to condemn what the U.S. contends is Iran's secret nuclear-weapons program. Iran says its nuclear activities are for peaceful purposes. U.S. officials acknowledge Iran is still years away from producing such weapons, but they say inspections of several facilities and other recently obtained intelligence have convinced the U.S. that Iran is working faster than previously known.
The U.S. has supplied Russia and other countries on the IAEA board with some of its intelligence, although a senior U.S. official says it remains unclear what findings the IAEA board will make when it meets next month. Imposing sanctions on Tehran through the United Nations Security Council for its nuclear activities will be difficult. Unlike Iraq and even North Korea, Iran has relations with many European countries and Russia, and their governments appear reluctant to jeopardize these ties by joining a campaign to isolate Tehran.
Complicating the policy debate is that U.S. officials are divided about how much of a threat such Iranian influence poses in Iraq. Some warn that Iran is trying to actively block U.S. hopes of installing a friendly regime in Baghdad. Israeli officials have told the White House that the same thing could happen to the U.S. in Iraq as happened to Israel's troops in southern Lebanon during the 1980s and 1990s. There, Iranian-backed Hezbollah Shiite militants fought a guerilla war that ultimately drove out the Israelis.
But other U.S. officials argue that Iran is waiting to see how events unfold, and how much political power fellow Shiites will have in Iraq. And it is weighing whether the U.S. is plotting to oust them from power next, says a senior U.S. intelligence official. The more threatening the Bush administration appears to Iranian officials in coming months, "the more active Tehran will be in Iraq to try to keep us tied down so we can't focus on them," predicted a U.S. intelligence official.
The Wall Street Journal
May 12, 2003
By DAVID S. CLOUD
When the Bush administration this month asked the Iranian government through intermediaries to turn over Iraqi officials or terrorists who crossed into their territory, a U.S. official says Tehran's reply was caustic: We had a deal to cooperate, and you haven't lived up to it.
The Iranians were upset that Washington hadn't followed through on prewar assurances that coalition forces invading Iraq would eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, an anti-Tehran militia group that for years has mounted cross-border attacks from Iraq.
The back-channel messages, which the official said were conveyed by British diplomats, show how a relationship that in some ways had been quietly improving after the war in Afghanistan has deteriorated since the invasion of Iraq. Now, U.S. officials accuse Tehran of sending agents to foment anti-U.S. sentiment among Iraq's Shiite Muslims, continuing to back anti-Israel terror groups and stepping up a clandestine nuclear-weapons program.
How the U.S. -- with thousands of troops on Iran's western flank -- confronts these issues has become a major foreign-policy question for the Bush administration. And the issue has revived an internal U.S. government debate about how to deal with Iran , a country the U.S. hasn't had formal relations with since Islamic clerics took power in a 1979 revolution.
Some State Department officials argue that the best way to improve Tehran's behavior, in addition to public pressure, is to quietly signal to people loyal to President Mohammad Khatami that Washington's goals in the region don't include the regime's ouster. If the Iranians don't feel threatened, these officials argue, they will be less apt to meddle in Iraq and may even decide that developing nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles is less urgent.
That view isn't shared by other administration officials. Some in the Pentagon and White House favor a more confrontational approach, based on their view that Iran's hard-line clerics retain too much authority to abandon policies objectionable to Washington without sustained pressure. They argue for steps aimed at destabilizing the Iranian regime from within, including a proposed $50 million fund for pro-democracy radio and satellite broadcasts into the country by Iranian-Americans.
"America must abandon any talk of engaging the self-proclaimed reformers [in Iran ] who have not reformed the system in the seven years they have been in power," says Sen. Sam Brownback, a Kansas Republican who is pushing the broadcasting fund in Congress.
Leading up to the Iraq war, the White House was much more inclined to woo Tehran than it is now. Despite fears about Iranian meddling after the U.S. war in Afghanistan, Iran played a constructive role after that conflict, supporting Hamid Karzai's fledgling government, said former State Department Afghanistan envoy James Dobbins.
U.S. officials hoped that would continue heading into the Iraq conflict. In January, White House aide Zalmay Khalilzad and State Department officials assured Iranian representatives at a meeting in northern Iraq that the imminent U.S. invasion wouldn't threaten -- and might even benefit -- Tehran. The Iranians were told that one of the U.S. war aims was to eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq, a longtime Iranian goal. In return, the U.S. asked Iran not to send armed fighters into Iraq, U.S. officials say. Neither side completely complied.
After the hostilities, the Pentagon negotiated a temporary cease-fire that confined the Mujahedin-e-Khalq to bases in eastern Iraq but allowed it to keep its weapons. The arrangement was described as temporary, but it stirred Iranians' fears that the U.S. wanted the group intact to harass them in the future.
Pentagon officials wrote a memo last month suggesting that the White House could consider naming the Mujahedin-e-Khalq "a legitimate Iranian opposition group," despite its status as a U.S.-designated terrorist group, according to a U.S. official who quoted from the document. A Pentagon spokesman denied the department had proposed the idea, but the group's future was discussed at a senior-level meeting two weeks ago, officials said. The State Department's top counterterrorism official, Cofer Black, argued that would undermine U.S. credibility when it asked other countries to crack down on terrorist groups. Mr. Bush sided with the State Department, and U.S. forces in Iraq now are moving to disarm and eliminate the Mujahedin-e-Khalq.
State Department officials say that decision at least in part is meant to reinforce the message that the U.S. isn't looking to meddle inside Iran -- just as Tehran shouldn't interfere in Iraq.
But U.S. officials say Iranian Revolutionary Guards -- militants loyal to Iran's hard-line clerics -- are seeking to play a role inside Iraq, both by infiltrating the country themselves and by working through Iraqi Shiite clerics, many of whom have spent years living in Iran . Even Iraqis whom the U.S. is counting on to play major roles in an interim Iraqi government have ties to Tehran. One U.S. official said Iranian agents are telling Iraqis that the U.S. doesn't have the stomach for the long haul and will be gone soon. "The message is, 'Don't get too close to the Americans,' " the official said.
Mr. Bush hasn't resolved the disagreement among his advisers, except to play down the option of using military force to achieve regime change in Iran . Secretary of State Colin Powell has little interest in attempting to hold direct talks with the Iranians, as he did recently with the Syrians. Officially, Iran continues to reject direct dialogue with the U.S., but Washington also has spurned what appear to be recent overtures from Tehran that seem to reflect hopes for better relations.
"We do have channels that we are using with the Iranians, and communicating to them that they ought to review their policies," Mr. Powell told reporters during the weekend. He played down the prospect of seeking better ties with Tehran, though. "The issue of diplomatic relations is not on the table right now, on either side."
Since the war ended, the administration has chosen a more confrontational path. Administration officials are trying to build support among governments that sit on the board of the International Atomic Energy Agency to condemn what the U.S. contends is Iran's secret nuclear-weapons program. Iran says its nuclear activities are for peaceful purposes. U.S. officials acknowledge Iran is still years away from producing such weapons, but they say inspections of several facilities and other recently obtained intelligence have convinced the U.S. that Iran is working faster than previously known.
The U.S. has supplied Russia and other countries on the IAEA board with some of its intelligence, although a senior U.S. official says it remains unclear what findings the IAEA board will make when it meets next month. Imposing sanctions on Tehran through the United Nations Security Council for its nuclear activities will be difficult. Unlike Iraq and even North Korea, Iran has relations with many European countries and Russia, and their governments appear reluctant to jeopardize these ties by joining a campaign to isolate Tehran.
Complicating the policy debate is that U.S. officials are divided about how much of a threat such Iranian influence poses in Iraq. Some warn that Iran is trying to actively block U.S. hopes of installing a friendly regime in Baghdad. Israeli officials have told the White House that the same thing could happen to the U.S. in Iraq as happened to Israel's troops in southern Lebanon during the 1980s and 1990s. There, Iranian-backed Hezbollah Shiite militants fought a guerilla war that ultimately drove out the Israelis.
But other U.S. officials argue that Iran is waiting to see how events unfold, and how much political power fellow Shiites will have in Iraq. And it is weighing whether the U.S. is plotting to oust them from power next, says a senior U.S. intelligence official. The more threatening the Bush administration appears to Iranian officials in coming months, "the more active Tehran will be in Iraq to try to keep us tied down so we can't focus on them," predicted a U.S. intelligence official.
Iran, U.S. holding talks in Geneva
USA TODAY
May 12, 2003
By Barbara Slavin
Iran's Islamic government is debating re-establishing diplomatic relations with the United States for the first time in 23 years and is holding secret talks with U.S. diplomats in Geneva on a range of issues, including the shape of a new government in Iraq, U.S. and Iranian diplomats say.
The Geneva discussions, due to resume next week, are headed on the U.S. side by Zalmay Khalilzad, President Bush's special envoy to the Iraqi opposition, the diplomats say. A representative of the United Nations opens the talks but does not always stay, U.S. officials say. There have been three meetings this year, the most recent on May 3.
The sessions, which grew out of earlier multilateral discussions on Afghanistan, are the sort of direct, high-level talks with Iran the United States has sought for years. Though U.S. diplomats meet with representatives of Iran's elected government, the talks have the explicit approval of Islamic clerics, who hold crucial decision-making power over Iran's foreign policy.
The meetings come as debate heats up in the Bush administration over how to deal with a country that has considerable influence in Iraq, is said to be developing nuclear weapons and is a major supporter of Palestinian and Lebanese militant groups.
The Bush administration has asked the International Atomic Energy Agency to declare Iran in violation of its nuclear non-proliferation pledges after discovery of an Iranian program to enrich uranium for use in nuclear weapons. But in a gesture toward Iran, U.S. forces in Iraq on Saturday began disarming the Mujahedin e-Khalq, an Iraq-based organization that violently opposes the Islamic government in Tehran.
Secretary of State Colin Powell, who was in the Middle East on Saturday to try to restart Arab-Israeli peace talks, confirmed that a dialogue with Iran was taking place but said restoration of formal relations was not on the horizon.
"The issue of diplomatic relations is not on the table right now for either side," Powell said. "But in terms of communicating with the Iranians, we have such ways, and we use them on a regular basis."
Although it is proceeding with talks, the Bush administration is divided over how to approach Iran. Some officials within the Pentagon and vice president's office see Iran as the next target for U.S.-backed regime change and are reluctant to shore up clerical rule there. Others, primarily in the State Department and National Security Council, regard contacts with Iran's existing government as necessary to restore stability in Iraq and make headway toward a Palestinian-Israeli peace agreement.
"The debate is taking place both in Iran and the United States," says an Iranian diplomat who asked not to be named. "We are ready to discuss re-establishing relations on the basis of mutual respect, equal footing and seriousness."
Last week, more than half the Iranian parliament — 154 of 290 members — issued a statement calling on the Foreign Ministry to restore relations with the United States. Opinion polls show more than 70% of Iran's 70 million people favor restoring ties cut by the United States in 1980 after Iranian students seized U.S. embassy hostages.
Moderates within the regime have favored restoring relations but have been stymied by hard-line clerics who regard the United States as Iran's chief ideological foe. That balance may be changing, however, as a result of the U.S. toppling of governments on either side of Iran, in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Last month, after the fall of Baghdad, former president Hashemi Rafsanjani, who is close to the country's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, suggested holding a referendum on re-establishing ties with the United States. Iranian Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi was quoted by Iran's news service last week as saying, "Iran wants to expand its relations with all countries, even with America."
May 12, 2003
By Barbara Slavin
Iran's Islamic government is debating re-establishing diplomatic relations with the United States for the first time in 23 years and is holding secret talks with U.S. diplomats in Geneva on a range of issues, including the shape of a new government in Iraq, U.S. and Iranian diplomats say.
The Geneva discussions, due to resume next week, are headed on the U.S. side by Zalmay Khalilzad, President Bush's special envoy to the Iraqi opposition, the diplomats say. A representative of the United Nations opens the talks but does not always stay, U.S. officials say. There have been three meetings this year, the most recent on May 3.
The sessions, which grew out of earlier multilateral discussions on Afghanistan, are the sort of direct, high-level talks with Iran the United States has sought for years. Though U.S. diplomats meet with representatives of Iran's elected government, the talks have the explicit approval of Islamic clerics, who hold crucial decision-making power over Iran's foreign policy.
The meetings come as debate heats up in the Bush administration over how to deal with a country that has considerable influence in Iraq, is said to be developing nuclear weapons and is a major supporter of Palestinian and Lebanese militant groups.
The Bush administration has asked the International Atomic Energy Agency to declare Iran in violation of its nuclear non-proliferation pledges after discovery of an Iranian program to enrich uranium for use in nuclear weapons. But in a gesture toward Iran, U.S. forces in Iraq on Saturday began disarming the Mujahedin e-Khalq, an Iraq-based organization that violently opposes the Islamic government in Tehran.
Secretary of State Colin Powell, who was in the Middle East on Saturday to try to restart Arab-Israeli peace talks, confirmed that a dialogue with Iran was taking place but said restoration of formal relations was not on the horizon.
"The issue of diplomatic relations is not on the table right now for either side," Powell said. "But in terms of communicating with the Iranians, we have such ways, and we use them on a regular basis."
Although it is proceeding with talks, the Bush administration is divided over how to approach Iran. Some officials within the Pentagon and vice president's office see Iran as the next target for U.S.-backed regime change and are reluctant to shore up clerical rule there. Others, primarily in the State Department and National Security Council, regard contacts with Iran's existing government as necessary to restore stability in Iraq and make headway toward a Palestinian-Israeli peace agreement.
"The debate is taking place both in Iran and the United States," says an Iranian diplomat who asked not to be named. "We are ready to discuss re-establishing relations on the basis of mutual respect, equal footing and seriousness."
Last week, more than half the Iranian parliament — 154 of 290 members — issued a statement calling on the Foreign Ministry to restore relations with the United States. Opinion polls show more than 70% of Iran's 70 million people favor restoring ties cut by the United States in 1980 after Iranian students seized U.S. embassy hostages.
Moderates within the regime have favored restoring relations but have been stymied by hard-line clerics who regard the United States as Iran's chief ideological foe. That balance may be changing, however, as a result of the U.S. toppling of governments on either side of Iran, in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Last month, after the fall of Baghdad, former president Hashemi Rafsanjani, who is close to the country's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, suggested holding a referendum on re-establishing ties with the United States. Iranian Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi was quoted by Iran's news service last week as saying, "Iran wants to expand its relations with all countries, even with America."
Iranian Fighters Based in Iraq Begin to Disarm
Los Angeles Times
May 12, 2003
By Eric Slater
AL KHALIS, Iraq, May 12 — A heavily armed Iranian opposition group that the U.S. has listed as a terrorist organization began handing over its weapons to U.S. troops in eastern Iraq on Sunday in exchange for security guarantees.
Under a deal reached Saturday, the several thousand members of Moujahedeen Khalq have seven days to relinquish all heavy weapons and equipment and turn themselves in. Members of the organization, which was backed by Saddam Hussein, also have agreed to be interviewed by intelligence officials.
"When finally accomplished, the peaceful resolution of this process will significantly contribute to a safe and secure environment for the people of Iraq," the U.S. Central Command in Doha, Qatar, said in a statement.
"Coalition forces are ensuring the security of" the Moujahedeen Khalq, Central Command said. The group fears retribution from Iranian groups as well as anti-Hussein forces.
Moujahedeen Khalq's capitulation comes less than a month after U.S. forces agreed to a cease-fire with the group, which is known by the initials MEK. That agreement, which let the group retain its weapons, drew criticism from Iran and sparked controversy in Washington.
Calling the cease-fire "a severe blow to America's prestige," Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi said last week that the deal "showed that the administration is not honest when it talked about terrorism."
Some U.S. officials have questioned the propriety of agreeing to a cease-fire with Moujahedeen Khalq, whose members have killed U.S. citizens.
But others argued that the U.S. should support the group, which has long opposed the Iranian government labeled by President Bush as part of an "axis of evil." And because Moujahedeen Khalq worked closely with Hussein's government, it may be a source of information on both the former Iraqi regime as well as on Iran.
It was unclear Sunday why the U.S. had struck a new agreement with Moujahedeen Khalq.
Although the cease-fire allowed the group to keep its weapons, the deal required it to stop operating checkpoints between its five main bases and the Iranian border. Reports have circulated here in Al Khalis, 30 miles north of Baghdad where the group has a camp, that the Moujahedeen Khalq raised the ire of Army officials by again setting up the checkpoints to monitor traffic along the border. Those reports, however, could not be confirmed.
The move to disarm Moujahedeen Khalq began Friday, when the U.S. sent tanks, armored personnel carriers and hundreds of troops to surround its compounds.
Army Maj. Gen. Ray Odierno of the 4th Infantry Division met that day with the group's secretary-general, Central Command said, and less than 24 hours later the group agreed to a new set of rules.
Members will be allowed to retain small arms for personal protection and wear their dark-green uniforms but otherwise will have little say over their activities for the foreseeable future.
By most definitions, the new agreement amounts to a surrender, but U.S. military officials have declined to call it that. Central Command dubbed the development "the voluntary consolidation of MEK forces."
At a U.S. Army base near one of the group's camps Sunday, Capt. Josh Felker, an Army spokesman, said, "This is not a surrender, it's a disarmament process. The MEK was never fighting coalition forces."
Founded in the 1960s by well-educated leftists, Moujahedeen Khalq is considered the largest and most violent group of exiles seeking to undermine the Iranian government.
In the early 1970s, with the group angry about U.S. support of the pro-Western shah of Iran, members of a Moujahedeen Khalq faction killed several U.S. soldiers and civilians working on defense contracts in the country. The group also supported and possibly aided the 1979 takeover of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran, during which 52 Americans were held hostage for 444 days.
In the 1980s, most of the group's members, including leader Maryam Rajavi and her husband, head of the military branch of the group, were forced into exile, and the group based itself in Paris. In 1986, the group found a new home in Iraq and set up bases to make cross-border raids into Iran.
In 1992, the organization carried out nearly simultaneous attacks against Iranian installations in 13 countries, demonstrating its international reach. In 1998, the group assassinated the head of Iran's prison system, and in 2000 it killed the acting director of the Iranian army.
On Sunday, the group's fighters declined to speak to reporters and asked that their pictures not be taken for fear that relatives in Iran would face retribution from the government.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Abrams tanks that had surrounded the camps Friday turned their barrels around and were protecting the sites.
"They are a very respected fighting force, and as such we are treating them" courteously, Felker said. "Even though they are recognized as a terrorist organization, basically we don't want to disrespect them. Coalition forces will not allow any other forces to occupy Iraq at this time."
May 12, 2003
By Eric Slater
AL KHALIS, Iraq, May 12 — A heavily armed Iranian opposition group that the U.S. has listed as a terrorist organization began handing over its weapons to U.S. troops in eastern Iraq on Sunday in exchange for security guarantees.
Under a deal reached Saturday, the several thousand members of Moujahedeen Khalq have seven days to relinquish all heavy weapons and equipment and turn themselves in. Members of the organization, which was backed by Saddam Hussein, also have agreed to be interviewed by intelligence officials.
"When finally accomplished, the peaceful resolution of this process will significantly contribute to a safe and secure environment for the people of Iraq," the U.S. Central Command in Doha, Qatar, said in a statement.
"Coalition forces are ensuring the security of" the Moujahedeen Khalq, Central Command said. The group fears retribution from Iranian groups as well as anti-Hussein forces.
Moujahedeen Khalq's capitulation comes less than a month after U.S. forces agreed to a cease-fire with the group, which is known by the initials MEK. That agreement, which let the group retain its weapons, drew criticism from Iran and sparked controversy in Washington.
Calling the cease-fire "a severe blow to America's prestige," Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi said last week that the deal "showed that the administration is not honest when it talked about terrorism."
Some U.S. officials have questioned the propriety of agreeing to a cease-fire with Moujahedeen Khalq, whose members have killed U.S. citizens.
But others argued that the U.S. should support the group, which has long opposed the Iranian government labeled by President Bush as part of an "axis of evil." And because Moujahedeen Khalq worked closely with Hussein's government, it may be a source of information on both the former Iraqi regime as well as on Iran.
It was unclear Sunday why the U.S. had struck a new agreement with Moujahedeen Khalq.
Although the cease-fire allowed the group to keep its weapons, the deal required it to stop operating checkpoints between its five main bases and the Iranian border. Reports have circulated here in Al Khalis, 30 miles north of Baghdad where the group has a camp, that the Moujahedeen Khalq raised the ire of Army officials by again setting up the checkpoints to monitor traffic along the border. Those reports, however, could not be confirmed.
The move to disarm Moujahedeen Khalq began Friday, when the U.S. sent tanks, armored personnel carriers and hundreds of troops to surround its compounds.
Army Maj. Gen. Ray Odierno of the 4th Infantry Division met that day with the group's secretary-general, Central Command said, and less than 24 hours later the group agreed to a new set of rules.
Members will be allowed to retain small arms for personal protection and wear their dark-green uniforms but otherwise will have little say over their activities for the foreseeable future.
By most definitions, the new agreement amounts to a surrender, but U.S. military officials have declined to call it that. Central Command dubbed the development "the voluntary consolidation of MEK forces."
At a U.S. Army base near one of the group's camps Sunday, Capt. Josh Felker, an Army spokesman, said, "This is not a surrender, it's a disarmament process. The MEK was never fighting coalition forces."
Founded in the 1960s by well-educated leftists, Moujahedeen Khalq is considered the largest and most violent group of exiles seeking to undermine the Iranian government.
In the early 1970s, with the group angry about U.S. support of the pro-Western shah of Iran, members of a Moujahedeen Khalq faction killed several U.S. soldiers and civilians working on defense contracts in the country. The group also supported and possibly aided the 1979 takeover of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran, during which 52 Americans were held hostage for 444 days.
In the 1980s, most of the group's members, including leader Maryam Rajavi and her husband, head of the military branch of the group, were forced into exile, and the group based itself in Paris. In 1986, the group found a new home in Iraq and set up bases to make cross-border raids into Iran.
In 1992, the organization carried out nearly simultaneous attacks against Iranian installations in 13 countries, demonstrating its international reach. In 1998, the group assassinated the head of Iran's prison system, and in 2000 it killed the acting director of the Iranian army.
On Sunday, the group's fighters declined to speak to reporters and asked that their pictures not be taken for fear that relatives in Iran would face retribution from the government.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Abrams tanks that had surrounded the camps Friday turned their barrels around and were protecting the sites.
"They are a very respected fighting force, and as such we are treating them" courteously, Felker said. "Even though they are recognized as a terrorist organization, basically we don't want to disrespect them. Coalition forces will not allow any other forces to occupy Iraq at this time."
Saturday, May 10, 2003
US says Iran opposition in Iraq agrees to disarm
Agence France Presse
May 10 2003
NORTHEASTERN IRAQ (AFP) - US forces struck a disarmament deal with the Iraq-based Iranian armed opposition, a group listed as a terrorist organization in the United States, a US general told AFP.
The People's Mujahedeen's thousands of guerrilla fighters and heavy weapons are to assemble in camps in Iraq under the control of the US-led coalition, said General Ray Odierno, commander of the US Army's 4th Infantry Division.
"It is not a surrender. It is an agreement to disarm and consolidate," Odierno said after winding up two days of talks with the group, which has been termed a terrorist organization by the US State Department, the European Union (news - web sites) and Iran.
Speaking at a Mujahedeen base near the Iranian border, the general said they appeared to be committed to democracy in Iran and their cooperation with the United States should prompt a review of their "terrorist" status.
"I would say that any organization that has given up their equipment to the coalition clearly is cooperating with us, and I believe that should lead to a review of whether they are still a terrorist organization or not," he said.
The Mujahedeen's 4,000 to 5,000 fighters -- many of whom were educated in the United States and Europe -- would gather at one camp in Iraq while their equipment, including scores of tanks, would be collected at another, Odierno said.
Both camps would be guarded by coalition forces and the weapons would not be available to the Mujahedeen "unless we agree to allow them to have access", the general said.
The fighters, including a large number of women, would not be categorized as prisoners of war but they would be under "coalition control." Their status would be decided by Washington at a later date.
They are likely to face brutal retribution if they are repatriated to Iran, while asylum in the United States could fuel charges of double standards (news - web sites) in the US fight against terrorism.
Asked what role they could play in the future of Iraq, Odierno said only that they shared similar goals to the United States in "forming democracy and fighting oppression" and that they had been "extremely cooperative."
US and Mujahedeen troops have mingled cordially during the discussions here over the past two days, although the US military was taking no chances with regular overflights by F-15 bombers and Apache attack helicopters.
Washington's dialogue with the Mujahedeen has infuriated Iran, which has accused the United States of hypocrisy in its "war on terror".
Also known by its Persian name Mujahedeen-e Khalq, the group has mounted major attacks inside Iran and has been fighting to overthrow the clerical regime in Tehran since shortly after it seized power.
US officers are concerned that if the group is rendered powerless, rival guerrillas from the Badr Brigade, the Iran-based military wing of the main Iraqi Shiite faction, will gain influence in the region.
May 10 2003
NORTHEASTERN IRAQ (AFP) - US forces struck a disarmament deal with the Iraq-based Iranian armed opposition, a group listed as a terrorist organization in the United States, a US general told AFP.
The People's Mujahedeen's thousands of guerrilla fighters and heavy weapons are to assemble in camps in Iraq under the control of the US-led coalition, said General Ray Odierno, commander of the US Army's 4th Infantry Division.
"It is not a surrender. It is an agreement to disarm and consolidate," Odierno said after winding up two days of talks with the group, which has been termed a terrorist organization by the US State Department, the European Union (news - web sites) and Iran.
Speaking at a Mujahedeen base near the Iranian border, the general said they appeared to be committed to democracy in Iran and their cooperation with the United States should prompt a review of their "terrorist" status.
"I would say that any organization that has given up their equipment to the coalition clearly is cooperating with us, and I believe that should lead to a review of whether they are still a terrorist organization or not," he said.
The Mujahedeen's 4,000 to 5,000 fighters -- many of whom were educated in the United States and Europe -- would gather at one camp in Iraq while their equipment, including scores of tanks, would be collected at another, Odierno said.
Both camps would be guarded by coalition forces and the weapons would not be available to the Mujahedeen "unless we agree to allow them to have access", the general said.
The fighters, including a large number of women, would not be categorized as prisoners of war but they would be under "coalition control." Their status would be decided by Washington at a later date.
They are likely to face brutal retribution if they are repatriated to Iran, while asylum in the United States could fuel charges of double standards (news - web sites) in the US fight against terrorism.
Asked what role they could play in the future of Iraq, Odierno said only that they shared similar goals to the United States in "forming democracy and fighting oppression" and that they had been "extremely cooperative."
US and Mujahedeen troops have mingled cordially during the discussions here over the past two days, although the US military was taking no chances with regular overflights by F-15 bombers and Apache attack helicopters.
Washington's dialogue with the Mujahedeen has infuriated Iran, which has accused the United States of hypocrisy in its "war on terror".
Also known by its Persian name Mujahedeen-e Khalq, the group has mounted major attacks inside Iran and has been fighting to overthrow the clerical regime in Tehran since shortly after it seized power.
US officers are concerned that if the group is rendered powerless, rival guerrillas from the Badr Brigade, the Iran-based military wing of the main Iraqi Shiite faction, will gain influence in the region.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)